Fellow Barber Styling Cream, $22; fellowbarber.com Malin + Goetz Hair Pomade, $22; malinandgoetz.com Lavett & Chin Hair Moisturizer, $28; mrporter.com Baxter of California Soft Water Pomade, $20; mrporter.com Patricks S2 Shine Finish Medium Hold Pomade, $60; mrporter.com