Why Colorful Gemstone Earrings Are the Perfect Alternative to Diamonds

gemstone earrings
Photo: Josh Olins

All products featured on Vogue are independently selected by our editors. However, we may receive compensation from retailers and/or from purchases of products through these links.

Colorful gemstones are often eclipsed by diamonds, but don’t underestimate what the flash of green, red, blue, or orange in a colorful earring can add to an ensemble. Think of the instant lift coral, turquoise, or malachite give a breezy white summer dress, or what emeralds, rubies, and sapphires give to a classic button-down shirt or a cocktail dress.

Embracing colored stones in earrings can bring a desired warm or cold tone to the face. They needn’t be the most complicated of earrings—often the best are simple. Jewelry designer Irene Neuwirth has made a name for herself with her whimsical designs that embrace stones of all hues. “I love using the same color values with different colors next to one another,” she says, “so when you squint your eyes, it looks similar, but when you look more closely, they are different.”

Just as with diamonds, there’s an ethical wave in the colored gemstone arena. Gemfields has made strides in responsibly sourcing gemstones. It has recently partnered with the conservation charity Space for Giants in partnership with Net-a-Porter to create a collection called Walk for Giants that raises money and awareness for conservation in Africa. Programs such as this make a colorful piece’s origins far less of a worry.

Neuwirth doesn’t give weight to one stone being better than another. “Any color! All the colors,” she says. Artist palettes at the ready: time to add some fun to your ear game.

Simple

As with many things in life, often a simple approach to gemstone earrings is the most successful. There’s no need to go wild to get the point across.

Image may contain: Pattern

Nouvel Heritage pink sapphire earrings

Image may contain: Accessories, Accessory, Jewelry, and Earring

Marlo Laz 14k yellow-gold and aquamarine diamond earrings

Image may contain: Accessories, Accessory, Jewelry, and Earring

Pomellato earrings Nudo

Image may contain: Accessories, Accessory, Jewelry, and Gemstone

Sylva Cie tourmaline and diamond 18k yellow-gold earrings

Studs and Huggies

Short and sweet, studs and huggie hoops that sit close to the earlobe are great ways to add some color into your jewelry.

Image may contain: Jewelry, Accessories, Accessory, Emerald, Gemstone, and Green

Aya x Gemfields exclusive emerald ear jacket earrings for Walk for Giants

Image may contain: Turquoise

Tiffany Co. Elsa Peretti Color by the Yard earrings

Image may contain: Accessories, Accessory, Jewelry, Earring, and Gemstone

Raphaele Canot Set Free diamond, tsavorite, and 18k-gold earrings

Image may contain: Accessories, Accessory, and Plant

Irene Neuwirth medium gumball hoops

Image may contain: Jewelry, Accessories, Accessory, and Gemstone

Ileana Makri tiny baguette eye stud

Image may contain: Plant, Fruit, and Food

Cartier Clash de Cartier earrings XL model

Drops

A touch longer, and a tad more bold, dangle drop gemstone earrings are a larger canvas for your chosen color palette.

Image may contain: Accessories, Accessory, Jewelry, and Earring

Sylva Cie jade and diamond 18k yellow-gold acorn earrings

Image may contain: Accessories, Accessory, and Jewelry

Irene Neuwirth one of a kind tropical flower earrings

Image may contain: Lighting

Dezso tourmaline shell and 18k-gold earrings

Image may contain: Accessories, Accessory, Jewelry, Earring, and Gemstone

Bulgari Allegra earrings

Image may contain: Accessories, Accessory, Jewelry, and Earring

Pippa Small 18k-gold ruby earrings

All Out

These fall under the “go big or go home approach” when it comes to color.

Image may contain: Accessories, Accessory, Jewelry, and Earring

Fernando Jorge Gravity diamond and serpentine 18k yellow-gold earrings

Image may contain: Accessories, Accessory, Jewelry, and Earring

Nina Runsdorf 18k yellow-gold, spessartite bead, and cabochon drop earrings

Image may contain: Accessories, Accessory, Jewelry, Earring, and Gemstone

Jessica McCormack Ball ’n’ Chain multishape emerald and diamond long earrings

Image may contain: Cone

Bina Goenka 18k-gold pearl and ruby earrings