Shay Mitchell Breaks Down Her 58-Step Beauty Guide, From Face Masks to False Eyelashes

All products featured on Vogue are independently selected by our editors. However, we may receive compensation from retailers and/or from purchases of products through these links.

“You’re going to see quite a few masks,” Shay Mitchell says on a recent morning in the latest installment of Vogue’s Beauty Secrets. Accordingly, out come de-puffing eye pads, a pout-smoothing sticker, and a lifting chin strap picked up during a trip to Japan. The Pretty Little Liars actor, who has over 31.3 million Instagram followers, even has 24-karat gold patches specifically suited to her décolletage. Such skin-saving steps are, in fact, only the beginning of Mitchell’s more-is-more beauty routine, which also includes a handful of moisturizing serums and creams; a top-secret aloe vera balm that she slathers around her eyes; and, perhaps most importantly, facial massage—and lots of it. As she puts it, “If I have time, I really go full out with my skin care… Why not? It feels good.”

With over 25 makeup products in her daily arsenal, much the same could be said about the 34-year-old’s approach to color cosmetics. Nevertheless, Mitchell does not try to shape shift; rather, “I really do just try to enhance what I have and work with it,” she explains, moments after deftly mixing together multiple shades of concealer, powder, and contour to reveal a seemingly air-brushed complexion, which she tops off with a sweep of Refy’s gloss highlighter; a number of pigments, including bubblegum-colored blush from Benefit and Kylie Cosmetics; and a smattering of dots meant to enhance her natural freckles. “That’s what I think makes people beautiful,” she muses, adding on a spritz of Cacharel’s Yes I Am Glorious eau de parfum, “when they just enhance what they were born with.” 

Below, shop Shay Mitchell’s Beauty Secrets. 

Filmed at The West Hollywood Edition

Image may contain: Bottle, Shaker, and Lotion

Shani Darden Skin Care Cleansing Serum

Image may contain: Tool, and Brush

ESARORA Ice Roller

Image may contain: Brochure, Paper, Advertisement, Flyer, Poster, Text, and Business Card

Patchology Lip Renewal FlashPatch 5-Minute Hydrogels

Image may contain: Brochure, Paper, Advertisement, Flyer, Poster, Text, and Page

Skyn Iceland Hydro Cool Firming Face Gels with Extensin and Peptides

Image may contain: Bottle, and Cosmetics

111SKIN Anti Blemish Bio Cellulose Facial Mask

Image may contain: Mouth, Teeth, Lip, Human, and Person

Avajar Perfect V-Lifting Premium Mask

Image may contain: Lamp, and Mask

Honest Reusable Magic Silicone Sheet Mask

Image may contain: Tool, and Brush

Nurse Jamie Uplift Facial Massaging Beauty Roller

Image may contain: Paper, and Text

Booby Tape 24K Gold Breast Masks

Image may contain: Cosmetics, and Deodorant

La Mer The Moisturizing Cool Gel Cream

Image may contain: Bottle

123 Farm Rose Face Serum

Image may contain: Clothing, Apparel, Swimwear, Cap, Hat, and Swimming Cap

Wilding Empress Stone

Image may contain: Tool, Brush, and Toothbrush

Shani Darden Skin Care Facial Sculpting Wand

Image may contain: Cosmetics, and Bottle

Kiehl s Creamy Eye Treatment With Avocado

Image may contain: Food, Bottle, and Shaker

Basic Organics E-Ointment

Image may contain: Cosmetics, Bottle, and Sunscreen

iS Clinical Super Serum Advance Plus

Image may contain: Bottle, Shaker, Cosmetics, and Deodorant

iS Clinical Eclipse SPF 50+

Image may contain: Bottle, Lotion, and Cosmetics

Aquaphor Lip Repair

Image may contain: Bottle, and Cosmetics

Tata Harper Illuminating Moisturizer

Image may contain: Cosmetics, and Bottle

Fenty Beauty What it Dew Makeup Refreshing Spray

Image may contain: Tape, Cosmetics, and Face Makeup

RCMA Color Process Foundation

Image may contain: Paint Container, Palette, Mailbox, and Letterbox

NYX 3C Color Correcting Concealer Palette

Image may contain: Mailbox, and Letterbox

Tom Ford Shade Illuminate

Image may contain: Cosmetics

Tarte Shape Tape Concealer

Image may contain: Marker

Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer

Image may contain: Sponge

Beautyblender Original

Image may contain: Tape, Cosmetics, and Face Makeup

Laura Mercier Translucent Loose Setting Powder

Image may contain: Cosmetics, Face Makeup, Tool, and Brush

Benefit Cosmetics Hoola Matte Bronzer Mini

Benefit Cosmetics GALifornia Sunny Golden Pink Blush Mini

Kelly Baker Brows Brow Defining Pencil

Image may contain: Cosmetics, Bottle, and Sunscreen

Got 2b Glued Spiking Glue

Image may contain: Paint Container, Palette, Mailbox, and Letterbox

Makeup By Mario Master Mattes Eyeshadow Palette

Surratt Relevée Lash Curler

Image may contain: Cosmetics, and Mascara

Benefit BADgal BANG! Volumizing Mascara

Ardell Duo Lash Adhesive Dark

Image may contain: Bottle, and Cosmetics

Refy Gloss Highlighter

Image may contain: Tool, Brush, and Toothbrush

Refy Duo Brush

Image may contain: Mailbox, Letterbox, and Cosmetics

Kylie Cosmetics We re Going Shopping Pressed Blush Powder

Buxom Power Line Plumping Lip Liner

Image may contain: Cosmetics

Elaluz Oil-Infused Lip Gloss

Image may contain: Cosmetics, and Lipstick

Kylie Cosmetics Koko K High Gloss

Image may contain: Cosmetics, and Lipstick

Cacharel Women s Yes I Am Glorious Eau De Parfum Spray