What the Oscars Red Carpet Would Look Like If Vogue Editors Had Their Way

Image may contain Adult Person Fashion Clothing Dress Formal Wear Footwear Shoe and Evening Dress
Photos: Erdem, Balenciaga by Isidore Montag / Gorunway.com; Chloé by Photo: Carlo Scarpato / Gorunway.com

The Academy Awards are taking place this weekend, and the only question that looms larger than “Barbie or Oppenheimer?” inside the brains of the pop-culture and fashion obsessed is: Which looks will walk the Oscars red carpet? The fall 2024 collections just ended this week, and our editors have pored through thousands of images from the season’s 300-plus shows, so who better to poll on the state of red-carpet dressing from the runways? We know that Vogue editors aren’t fortune tellers, but when five separate editors mention Balenciaga’s strapless blue sequined gown…well, it would be crazy if it didn’t end up on the red carpet, no? Scroll through to see our dream red-carpet scenario—and check back in after the show to see if we got any right!

Image may contain Fashion Adult Person Clothing Dress Footwear Shoe Accessories Wallet and Runway

Louis Vuitton

Umberto Fratini / Gorunway.com

Virginia Smith, Global Head of Fashion Network
The amazing fringe-y finale looks at Vuitton were some of the best evening looks of the season—I’m hoping they headed straight to LA after the show.

Image may contain Liu Wen Clothing Dress Fashion Formal Wear Gown Wedding Wedding Gown Adult Person and Standing

The Row

Jamie Hawkesworth / Courtesy of The Row
Diotima

Diotima

Diedre Lewis / Courtesy of Diotima

Mark Guiducci, Creative Editorial Director
I’d love to see that rich turquoise look from Balenciaga on Greta Lee, who is not even nominated but deserves to go just for her fashion choices of late. It would also be exciting to see someone wear Look 23 from The Row or the final look in Diotima’s collection.

Image may contain Fashion Clothing Dress Formal Wear Person Adult Evening Dress Accessories Bracelet and Jewelry

Balenciaga

Isidore Montag / Gorunway.com

Nicole Phelps, Global Director of Vogue Runway
My vote goes to the strapless turquoise sequined number from Balenciaga. That color! Those subtle accents at the hips! A winner, any way you look at it.

Image may contain Fashion Clothing Long Sleeve Sleeve Coat Robe Formal Wear Adult Person Dress Suit and Gown

Rochas

Courtesy of Rochas

Chloe Malle, Editor, Vogue.com
Go straight from the red carpet onto a red-eye in Rochas’s pillow-like ice blue satin puffer and slip. The drape of the dress is just nonchalant enough and can meet any carpet-pile height with aplomb!

Image may contain Pat Cleveland Fashion Clothing Footwear High Heel Shoe Adult Person Accessories and Jewelry

Chloé

Carlo Scarpato / Gorunway.com

Leah Faye Cooper, Digital Style Director, Vogue.com
Do you know what Chloé fall 2024 did to me? Probably not because I can’t even articulate how utterly moved I was by Chemena Kamali’s debut collection. I can’t stop thinking about this magical white lace dress. Is a sheer boho moment formal enough for the Oscars? Maybe not. Do I want to see it anyway? Yes. There must be a stylist out there who can work their magic with the help of the right undergarments and a great shoe. Please and thank you.

Image may contain Person Standing Adult Fashion Performer and Solo Performance

Chanel

Photo: Umberto Fratini / Gorunway.com

Arden Fanning Andrews, Beauty Editor at Large
I like it when it at least looks like celebs self-styled during awards season. So the ribbed long-sleeve and silky mystery of Chanel’s almost-finale look reads like a heavenly earth angel who’s listening to ’90s Blink-182 in the car to the carpet.

Image may contain Kristine Froseth Clothing Coat Fashion Adult Person Cape Glove Footwear High Heel and Shoe

Rochas

Courtesy of Rochas
Image may contain Clothing Dress Evening Dress Formal Wear Adult Person Fashion Gown Footwear Shoe and Runway

Duran Lantink

Umberto Fratini / Gorunway.com
Ashlyn

Ashlyn

Courtesy of Ashlyn
Image may contain Blouse Clothing Cape Fashion Adult and Person

Sharon Wauchob

James Cochrane / Courtesy of Sharon Wauchob

Laird Borrelli-Persson, Senior Archive Editor
There are a few looks I would love to see on the red carpet this season: Rochas’s nod to Pagliacci, with pistachio satin and black lace that conjure a commedia dell’arte heroine; the walking Hans Arp by Duran Lantink, who is reshaping fashion with softly padded curves; Ashlynn Park’s gentle, asymmetric take on tuxedo dressing that brings to mind the silhouettes of Paul Poiret; and, finally, Sharon Wauchob’s new spin on bias dressing.

Image may contain Person Clothing Dress Evening Dress Formal Wear Adult Standing and Fashion

Carven

Paolo Lanzi / Gorunway.com
Image may contain Person Adult and Fashion

Erdem

Photo: Isidore Montag / Gorunway.com
Image may contain Fashion Clothing Dress Formal Wear Adult Person Evening Dress Helmet Hat and Child

Jil Sander

Alessandro Lucioni / Gorunway.com

Laia Garcia-Furtado, Senior Fashion News Editor
I feel like we’re entering a new era of red-carpet dressing tailor-made for the internet’s fashion fanatics, which is great because that’s literally us! Someone who is presenting or otherwise not nominated could create a real moment for themselves in this little pleated dress from Carven; it’s deceptively simple and elegant and could really be elevated with some great hair and makeup and fabulous earrings. I would love to see America Ferrera in this gorgeous Erdem look—it’s sexy and fun (and oh, how it would pop against the once-again-red red carpet!)—or this opulent yet tattered silver Jil Sander on Sandra Hüller. The fashion girlies are counting on you!

Image may contain Clothing Glove Fashion Adult Person Accessories Glasses Footwear Shoe High Heel Bag and Handbag

Miu Miu

Daniele Oberrauch / Gorunway.com

Margaux Anbouba, Senior Beauty Editor
Mrs. Prada will always be my queen of bows because she knows how to use them without going cheesy or saccharine. I love this dress, which feels like a youthful, modern take on that snoozy Breakfast at Tiffany’s moment everybody has seared into their brain for all of eternity. But what makes it interesting—and fun—is the pairing of the clavicle-to-belly-button cutout topped off with a tonal bow. Audrey Hepburn wouldn’t, but somebody should.

Image may contain Alek Wek Fashion Accessories Jewelry Necklace Adult Person Bag and Handbag

Bottega Veneta

Filippo Fior / Gorunway.com
Alaïa

Alaïa

Photo: Courtesy of Alaïa
Image may contain Fashion Adult Person Clothing Footwear Shoe High Heel Cape Accessories Bag and Handbag

Louis Vuitton

Umberto Fratini / Gorunway.com
Image may contain Coumba Gawlo Clothing Dress Adult Person Standing Sleeve Formal Wear Fashion Face and Head

Marni

Courtesy of Marni

José Criales Unzueta, Fashion News Writer
Bottega red leather fringe on Julianne Moore! Alaïa blue dress on Ariana Grande! Vuitton closing look on Saoirse Ronan! Marni anything!

Image may contain Pat Cleveland Fashion Clothing Footwear High Heel Shoe Adult Person Long Sleeve Sleeve and Hat

Chloé

Carlo Scarpato / Gorunway.com

Christian Allaire, Fashion and Style Writer
I loved the beautiful bohemian dresses at Chloé. To me, they could make for a not-so-stuffy approach to evening dressing. Paired with a great heel and diamonds? It would be a mo-ment. Plus, it’s a killer color.

Image may contain Clothing Dress Adult Person Evening Dress Formal Wear Footwear High Heel and Shoe

Supriya Lele

Courtesy of Supriya Lele

Hannah Jackson, Fashion Writer
I’d love to see someone wear this light-as-air Supriya Lele. The silhouette and color are within traditional Oscar bounds, but the sheerness makes it perfectly on trend for 2024. I can only imagine how well the low-contrast paisley embellishments would pop with all the flashes illuminating it.

Image may contain Clothing Coat Long Sleeve Sleeve Glove Adult Person Fashion Costume Dress Footwear and Shoe

Rochas

Courtesy of Rochas
Simone Rocha for Jean Paul Gaultier Couture

Simone Rocha for Jean Paul Gaultier Couture

Photo: Isidore Montag / Gorunway.com

Irene Kim, Production and Editorial Coordinator Vogue Runway
I really, really love the new Rochas collection by Alessandro Vigilante, particularly the opening look. I think it is just a bit quirky, just a bit bold, and perfect to stand out among the rest on any red carpet. And I know the ask was for a ready-to-wear look, but I would love to see someone wear this gown from Simone Rocha’s collection for Jean Paul Gaultier Couture. It’s too bad the Oscars red carpet is going back to red this year because this would’ve looked impeccable on the champagne carpet!

Image may contain Clothing Dress Formal Wear Fashion Gown Wedding Wedding Gown Person Adult and Electrical Device

Richard Quinn

Photo: Filippo Fior / Gorunway.com
Image may contain Maria Simon Person Clothing Dress Adult Electrical Device Microphone Formal Wear and Child

Richard Quinn

Photo: Filippo Fior / Gorunway.com

Lucy Dolan-Zalaznick, Senior Associate, Creative Development, Social + Visuals
I think the two most interesting categories of red-carpet dressing are (1) what women of a certain age wear on the carpet and (2) how teen/child actors avoid looking like they’re on Toddlers Tiaras or My Super Sweet Sixteen. Enter Richard Quinn, who has ample looks for both categories. Look 11 has all the drama and elegance appropriate for someone like Annette Bening or Meryl Streep, without sacrificing fun. Look 18 has a youthful quality with the pink flower appliqués, shorter hem, and square jacket-inspired top but remains a veritable evening gown.